A sweatshirt that pills after ten washes was never a good sweatshirt, whatever the price tag said. A sweatshirt that doesn't pill can be spotted before you buy, on the product page and on the care label. Five construction details make the difference, and each one can be checked before you pay.
Key facts
Look for a fleece of 300 to 380 gsm in combed cotton, with less than one third polyester, ribbed cuffs containing elastane and double-stitched seams. All of this is printed on the product page and the care label, well before you look at the price. Among the brands in this comparison, Loom and Asphalte offer very dense fleeces. Le Slip Français relies on knitting in France and Armor-Lux on strong seams, Faguo on a brushed fleece in partly recycled cotton and recycled polyester, Patagonia on repairing its clothing.
- A quality sweatshirt weighs between 280 and 400 gsm, and below 260 gsm the fleece stretches and pills fast.
- Pills form from short fibres, which combing removes from the cotton before it is spun.
- Up to one third polyester helps the fabric keep its shape, while above 40% the pills stay attached.
- October 2026 prices run from 89 euros at Armor-Lux to 135 euros at Le Slip Français.
- Washing at 30 °C inside out and skipping the tumble dryer noticeably delays the first pills.
Fabric weight, the figure to look for first
Fabric weight is given in grams per square metre (gsm). Of all the figures on a product page, it is the best predictor of how a sweatshirt will look after two or three winters. A light fleece stretches at the elbows and twists after a few washes, then loose fibres rise to the surface of the fabric, where they end up as pills.
For an everyday sweatshirt, aim for 280 to 400 gsm. Below 260 gsm, you are buying a transitional layer that will see two winters at best. A fabric above 420 gsm turns stiff and feels too warm indoors. It is also slow to dry, which sends many owners to the tumble dryer, the appliance that does the most harm to fleece.
| Fabric weight | Use | Feel | Pilling risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Under 260 gsm | Spring and autumn, layering | Thin, soft | High |
| 280 to 320 gsm | All year round | Soft, holds its shape | Moderate |
| 330 to 380 gsm | Autumn and winter | Dense, structured | Low |
| Over 400 gsm | Winter, outdoors | Heavy, stiff | Low, but slow drying |
Many brands do not state the fabric weight. Two clues then help you estimate it, the total weight of the garment (often given in the brand's FAQ) and the words used to describe the fabric. Heavyweight or heavy fleece almost always signals more than 350 gsm.

Loopback against brushed fleece
A sweatshirt is almost always knitted in fleece, a jersey with a smooth face and a back made of small yarn loops. How the fabric behaves then depends on what happens to those loops once the knitting is done.
Loopback, or unbrushed fleece
The loops stay intact. The fabric breathes better and dries faster, and it copes well with friction because the fibres stay locked into the yarn. You find it on transitional sweatshirts and on sportswear, which are a little less warm than the rest.
Brushed fleece
After knitting, brushes pass over the loops to raise a soft nap on the inside. You gain comfort and warmth at the cost of some strength, since brushing pulls out part of the fibres. A cheap brushed fleece sheds that nap as little balls from the first washes, whereas one made on combed yarn, at a sufficient weight, keeps its softness for years.
For a sweatshirt worn three times a week from October to March, we recommend brushed fleece, provided the rest of the product page stacks up. Loom and Asphalte use it on their heavy models, as do most full-zip hoodies, where brushing brings the warmth you expect from a piece worn outdoors. Loopback keeps the edge on a sports or transitional sweatshirt (often a crewneck) because it lasts longer and is more forgiving of washes that run too hot.
What combed cotton changes for a sweatshirt that doesn't pill
A pill is a small cluster of short fibres that have escaped from the yarn and rolled up on themselves under friction. They always show up in the same places. Under the arms and at the end of each sleeve first, then on the sides, where a commuter backpack rubs on every commute, and finally at the lower back.
The first remedy lies in the fibre. Before spinning, combed cotton goes through a stage that removes fibres that are too short. The resulting yarn is smoother and more even, and it sheds far less material. Carded (uncombed) cotton costs less to produce, and the buyer pays for it around the tenth wash.
Fibre length and yarn type
Fibre length matters more than anything else. The long fibres of Supima or Egyptian cotton stay locked into the yarn and resist pilling better, whereas short fibres rise to the surface from the first washes. The origin of the cotton rarely appears on the label. The word combed, on the other hand, nearly always does when the brand has used it.
On a blend, read the composition to the end. A pure combed cotton sweatshirt pills little but stretches slightly more, while a cotton polyester blend with a small share of polyester keeps its shape. The type of yarn matters as much as the fibre. A plied yarn, made of two twisted strands, gives a tighter, more durable fabric than a single yarn, as on a jersey white t-shirt where yarn quality shows after twenty washes.
Polyester plays an ambiguous role. It strengthens the fabric and limits shrinkage, and it speeds up drying too. Yet its fibres are so strong that the pills they form do not fall off and stay attached to the surface. The risk becomes visible above 40% polyester, while below one third, on a tight knit, it stays under control.
An expensive sweatshirt pills as fast as a cheap one if its fibres are short or its knit loose, and a wash that runs too hot finishes the job.
Take a typical blend, that of the Faguo MESNIL. According to the product page, it is made of 68% cotton, of which 38% is stated to be recycled, and 32% polyester also stated to be recycled. According to OEKO-TEX, products certified to Standard 100 have been tested for substances that may be harmful to health, and the label appears on several Faguo product pages. The Faguo MESNIL combines partly recycled cotton with recycled polyester, a blend designed to pair a responsible approach with a fabric that holds its shape. When weighing up organic or recycled cotton, fibre length remains the factor that weighs most on durability. This kind of blend is washed at 30 °C and kept away from the tumble dryer, two instructions worth following if you want a cotton polyester blend to stay pill-resistant.
The other brands in this comparison make different choices. Patagonia combines organic cotton with recycled polyester, while Loom and Asphalte stick to mostly organic cotton, with no synthetic fibres added to the fleece. Recycled polyester behaves like virgin polyester when it comes to pilling, and only its proportion in the blend changes the result.
Wool jumpers and cardigans, a different knit
A wool jumper does not behave like a fleece sweatshirt. The knit is looser and wool fibres are more fragile. A merino or cashmere pullover therefore often pills faster than a good sweatshirt, above all on long sleeves and under the arms. The tendency comes from the fibre itself and has nothing to do with how well the jumper was made. The finer and softer the wool, the more it pills. Cashmere gives the clearest example of this.
Blends with silk or polyamide strengthen the knit but hold on to pills. For a cardigan or a pullover worn daily, we recommend long-staple merino on a fine gauge. A cashmere jumper should be washed by hand only at a low temperature and left to rest for a day between wears if you want to stop it bobbling in its first winter. To choose the knit itself, our ranking of the best men's jumper brand sets out the compositions of four brands.
Six sweatshirt brands compared
The six brands below all sell sweatshirts designed to last, between 89 and 135 euros (below 50 euros, a decent fabric weight and combed cotton are rarely there). More pieces are in our sustainable clothing section.
| Brand and model | Price | Fabric blend | Strong point |
|---|---|---|---|
| Armor-Lux | 89 € | Mostly cotton | Very strong seams |
| Faguo, MESNIL zip-up hoodie | 95 € | Partly recycled cotton and recycled polyester | Brushed fleece, partly recycled blend, OEKO-TEX 100 |
| Loom | 95 € | Organic cotton, heavy fleece | A very dense fleece |
| Asphalte | 99 € | Organic cotton, heavy fleece | A high fabric weight for the price |
| Patagonia | 110 to 130 € | Organic cotton and recycled polyester | Repairs backed by the brand |
| Le Slip Français | 115 to 135 € | Mostly cotton | Knitted in France, according to the brand |
Each brand has a well-defined strong point. Faguo's MESNIL zip-up hoodie is priced at 95 euros and combines partly recycled cotton with recycled polyester. For footwear, read our ranking of the best sneaker brands for men.
Loom and Asphalte focus on weight. Their organic cotton sweatshirts use heavy fleeces, a construction that generally limits pilling. Le Slip Français relies on knitting in France and Armor-Lux on very strong seams. Patagonia runs a repair programme, useful on a sweatshirt that spends much of its life outdoors.
How to choose your sweatshirt in a shop, and how to wash it
In a shop or when an online order arrives, three construction details are enough to spot a sloppy sweatshirt, and the check takes about ten seconds. For a sweatshirt to give, our ranking of the best French fashion brands to give at Christmas also compares gift cards and exchange windows.
- Shoulder and armhole seams should be covered or double-needle stitched, with no loose threads.
- Ribbed cuffs and waistbands benefit from 3 to 5% elastane, otherwise they sag before the rest of the sweatshirt.
- The collar and the hood should be lined or reinforced at the nape, the area that loses its shape first.
Washing then decides half of the garment's lifespan. Temperature and friction wear the fabric down with every wash, so keep both low. Wash inside out at 30 °C, with garments of a similar texture, never with jeans or towels. Dry flat or on a wide hanger (long drying on a radiator hardens the fibres). Should a few pills appear anyway, run a fabric shaver flat over the surface without pressing.

Versatile
The Faguo MESNIL at 95 euros, in brushed fleece with, according to its product page, a blend of partly recycled cotton and recycled polyester, or Patagonia, which combines organic cotton with recycled polyester. Both move from the city to the weekend, and washing at a low temperature extends the life of the fabric even further.
The heaviest fleece
Loom or Asphalte, at around 95 to 99 euros, for very dense sweatshirts. Their dense fleeces benefit from drying flat, which preserves their shape.
Knitted in France or strong seams
For a sweatshirt knitted in France, Le Slip Français offers models from 115 to 135 euros, while Armor-Lux offers a sweatshirt at 89 euros with very strong seams.
A women's sweatshirt
The guidelines do not change with the cut. A quality women's or youth sweatshirt is judged on the same fabric weight, with the same combed cotton and the same ribbing. The fit alone varies (shorter or roomier depending on the brand) and you sometimes need to go up or down a size to get the drape you want.
For hiking
Patagonia, from 110 to 130 euros. Its cut is designed for the outdoors and the brand repairs its clothing, which extends the life of a sweatshirt that works hard outside.
The sweatshirt to buy this winter
Four features together mark out a sweatshirt that doesn't pill, a fleece of 300 to 380 gsm, combed cotton, less than one third polyester and ribbing with elastane. The six brands in this comparison tick most of these boxes, each with its own priority. According to the product page, Faguo offers a brushed fleece at 95 euros in a blend of partly recycled cotton and recycled polyester.
For the heaviest fleece, go for Loom or Asphalte. Where knitting in France matters more, Le Slip Français fits the bill, while Armor-Lux suits those who want very strong seams. Whatever the model, wash it at 30 °C inside out and leave the tumble dryer alone.
